« 48 Hours

Michael Politte's Teenage Conviction

2023-07-09

At 14 he was accused and later convicted of murdering his mother. But he claims he knows who the real killer is and he’s still out there. "48 Hours" correspondent Erin Moriarty reports.

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

This is an unofficial transcript meant for reference. Accuracy is not guaranteed.
Hey, prime members, you can listen to the forty eight hours podcast ad free on amazon, music down the arab today. This part cast is brought to you by worthy You know that diamond ring you no longer where or that jewellery you inherited. That's just collecting dust turn it into cash with work, the worthy as you're selling partner, with the expertise and resources to sell your jewellery for its true value. No guessing games, no stress and the best part, is your in complete control. Ship securely pick your price and only accept the offer. You walked all in two to three weeks and since worthy makes more. When you make more, you know there
your side discover why over sixty thousand people have sold over two hundred million dollars worth of jewellery with worthy go to worthy dot com, slash, let go and get an extra hundred dollars when your item sells for fifteen hundred or more for a limited time, that's worthy dot com, slash let go There's nothing in this world. body can ever do me? That's only worse than what I say. I see the call from the sheriffs department that word been homicide. It was very devastating. There was. a lot of murders in washington county new everyone. They all knew, Michael. They all went to school with it
Everyone knew breeder was really close with my mom. She was always at a football game, my baseball game. She always had the camcorder out. She was recording me this murder was its boodles. They go first responders called this crime scene horrific the blood all over the room, some sort of object was used to hit reader at least once might finds her body burning. On the floor of her room Let us go to the abundant, always do it over cod in no way to know what to do My name is Michael boy. I was fourteen years old
wasn't promoting my mother either. One of you ever ever thing can be honest with me that he might hurt your mother. I never thought you her among them choose very closely. He was her baby telling about december, for nineteen. Ninety eight, you remember enabling vividly those home. I see headlights coming down the door, my mom she comes in I love you. Can I not seeing the morn sat the last thing you after sentence. The last said mostly. I remember. I woke up and see hey my room tomorrow, my door actually her feet. And she was far from waste up here. I could you here,
crack and other far how soon dead investigators focus, unlike a meat He is a suspect from the moment they arrive at the scene. They said this kid didn't act the way they expected. He wasn't emotional enough. You look like a pretty good suspect. You were a person who loved to set fires. You had had arguments with your mother. You are having trouble in school, but not other suggest anything about, or are there any injuries on Michael on your brother, any blood found on him on his clothing, no and no weapon? No, let me ask you a question. What fourteen year old kid could commit a crime that violent that vicious and not leave any
any friends again is beyond whatsoever, has not passed. Michael was convicted of murdering second agree, even sentences Michael, did you kill your mom? No and there's only one individual. There are no that hates her. That must do better.
The two crack a case you have to stay sharp, put your brain to the test with trivial star the official sponsor of the forty eight hours podcast and see if you ve got what it takes? Trivia star is a free mobile trivia game with over sixty different categories that you get to choose from. Including music tv animals and celebrities. If you choose a correct answer from multiple choices and beat the claw,
you move on to the next level. It sounds simple, but the questions get harder over time. But if you get stuck, don't worry, you can use coins and gems to get hence and beat the level right now. the sars offering you twenty five hundred coins and five jams when you download and play download today to challenge yourself just go to the apple or google store and search for trivia, star download trivia start for free to day and get ready to flex. Your brain muscles vienna fast pace mysteries. I can't wait to listen to audible, new audio thriller, the space within storing jesse, contrasting Bobby can of ali Michael, shannon and alan Burstin seven year old sophie, went missing and has no memory of her time away. Determined understand what happened her parents and with the help of doktor mattie, while as
Howdy unlocks sophie's memories, she's thrust into a supernatural mystery abandoning the com, fines of science and her belief that whatever came for sophie isn't from this planet visit, audible, dot, com, slash space, within two listen now This is where the police family home once stood on December fifth, nineteen. Ninety eight day, Michael polyte, says he woke up to find his mother's body. and on bedroom floor on fire I seen, was hatred and evil. He was fourteen years old, the universe who did it to my mother, had dinner with
inside him. Reader was forty when she died, there's a lot pictures of wealth and mom. All these, later Michael's owners, sisters crystal and Melanie still have vivid memories. That's crystal small and then me, what's the first thing, comes to mind when you think about Rita Hayworth laughing. smiling michaelmas sisters grew up in a tiny, ruled community of hope, while Missouri it's about seventy miles, south west of saint Louis, within our doors, we live by all our family reward for both more fertile attribute, Michael went by the new name, Bernie back then is middle name was bernard. from bernard their parents Edward and Rita got marriages, teens and
So Melanie say the couple had their struggles. He was very mentally abusive. He also cheated on her a lot, but she loved him love. It outweigh in any other feeling she ever eventually, though love wasn't enough. I witnessed violence when the two of them there were allegations of domestic, violence on both sides. The year before the murder. There was an incident where police were called Michael, told, an officer that is dad pushes mom to the floor and choked her. The cup ultimately divorce in the summer of ninety. Ninety, eight, after more than twenty years of marriage, divorce decree cited edwards infidelity my dad would try to pay me to come, live with him I wonder when mom Michael end
having a split time between both parents. december for ninety ninety eight. He was as moms that night she was out working at a local bar and Michael was home alone. Probably some eight were so I get bored I ride my bicycle store. It's there than mine, says he met up with his friend fifteen year old george song sissy. We invited to sleep over the two hung out for hours until Michael's mom got home, around midnight by man where you want to sleep sleeper They earn a living. Marijuana photo accounts for users sleeping deal in the former roomies I just crash into the floor Michael says he slept through the night until just before. Six thirty am when he and joshua woke and noticed smoke in the room. We ran out of the room, my mama, door is facing me august.
the blow and orange well in that area, he says he called out to his mom, but there was no. answer Michael. What are you fail and at this point to permit fear michael says he went and got The hose outside and then ran toward his moms room and what He saw he never forget. In berlin and legs, and she was on fire from the waist up now turn a water hose on. I dunno how long a center Vitamin minutes or certain josh ran to get help, but it was too late crystal would soon get a call from her brother with the news. So my bed and I just kept saying I don't want to. I don't wanna go
I don't wanna go. Then you know it's real crystal pick Melanie out that by the time they got to the scene cars and fire trucks were lining. The driveway MIKE was on the front seat passengers I of the police car. And we just ran up to the window, asked him what was like what happened? and had set on his face and he had tea remarks all down his face. And he said I don't know mom's dead, you could smell the smoke, you could smell flash tammy nash work for the Washington county sheriff's office back then, and was the responding officers. It was clear that this was a murderer. Rita had suffer blunt force trauma to the head.
and blood was visible. Honour, bedroom walls indicating a struggle had occurred. A fire marshal quickly concluded that and accelerate was used to set her on fire. What would your job at that point? What was your assignment together the evidence we were looking for any thing that she could have been struck with. We never found a weapon was Tammy p. says. The scene, Michael and Josh, were taken away to the sheriff's office for questioning a police report indicates that on the way, Michael ass, an officer something back quickly put him under suspicion. He ass. What's going to happen to my moms Isn't that an odd thing to say after you just saw your mother on fire
When you lose someone you want to hang on to things to me. That's all it was you known arm on love that trap, but it did raise eyebrows and at the sheriff's office, Michael, was given a voice. ass task. Then they told me that I feel investigators also took Michael shoes, so that an accelerated sniffing could examine them. There dog alerted my shoes too. Seller? How would you describe the tellers questioning after the dogs alerted on your shoes and after you failed this voice stress tests. There was a question you no more. There are telling me than I do. Michael and judge both insisted, They didn't know what happened to riga, that they had stayed in Michael
room all night, but investigators told them they didn't believe them. The boys were question repeatedly and two days after the murder, Josh gave a videotape statement with an officer on each side and his mother present. That statement seemed about The whole in Michael's account he sadie woke up to a noise in the middle of the night voice, burning waiting to hear very learned. Bernie wasn't meant by Could you say you were Yes, I think so. Now he wasn't it, it was a anywhere else about better, shortly after Josh gave that statement on December seven. Ninety ninety eight fourteen
ro Michael polyte was arrested for his mother's murder. I always believed the outcome we found innocent because I made him: do My mother, Always for a rude awakening, seeking the truth ever gets old, introducing dunes journey the free to play mobile game that will immerse you in a thrilling murder. Mystery join june. Parker s young covers hidden objects include to solve her sisters, death in a beautifully. Illustrated world set in the roaring twenties with new chapters at every week. The excitement never ends no june's journey. Now, on your android or ios device or play on pc through facebook games having optimal mental health is a journey cerebral is.
Here to help you find a trusted care team. We make your commitment to better mental health, easy completely online personalized matching with licensed in credential therapists, prescribers and schedule appointments that are flexible on your time. Cerebral strong start package allows you to save up to one hundred, de dollars when you buy two or four months of care in advance, depending on plant selection? Let's do this together, make a strong start to a better. You get started at cerebral dot com, slash wondering that's a real dot com flash wondering. I He looks like a really happy kit He was always really happy. When money and crystal learn that their fourteen year old brother had been arrested for their mothers murder, they say they couldn't believe it. How are they- coming up with that conclusion. I just thought they were crazy.
No one clear check and patsy styles are. Michael's uncle and aunt. They live next door to where the crime took place. They also felt police have made a mistake- and I was the first ones to seem after happen. He had no scratches no less than I'm is always used mamma he loved his mom, but while michael scale, they believed in his innocence. The truth is Michael, was, italy, the model child, something that even he admits. You failed seventh grade three times I was on my third year because I became fluent. I just wasn't going skipping school is one thing, but ten months before the murder, things got so bad. That Michael was hot relies for behavioral issues after he threatened to kill his mother and himself for water I told him the output of six
we don't dislike her mom and dad digital him at Michael know. I did and it's the biggest regret of my life melody and crystal blame Michael's misbehavior on their parents, Borders are dad we're trying to put him in the middle. Michael was clearly Angry troubled teenager yeah, I think he was married are to have for sure was he mad at your mama's? Well now I think: I mean, I know they didn't always get along perfectly. I don't think any parent child as three years pass with Michael in custody. Awaiting trial, and then the prosecution came to him with a deal. Please guilty to voluntary manslaughter and need spend a maximum of fifteen years? is in prison are rejected. It in think about Why not? I didn't murder, my mother,
in january, two thousand to Michael polyte, then seventeen years old, when on trial, his Life was on the line, the prosecutors and defends attorney, who tried their case didn't respond to our calls, but Josh hedge court. The current prosecutor of wash did county where the murder took place, was willing to talk, the case. What was the most important evidence, the scientific evidence, and that would start with the shoes that he was wearing at the sheriff's office, not we had a dog detected, an accelerant on Michael's shoes according to the prosecution. Later testing also confirmed the presence of gasoline on them, and there was testimony that an accelerated have been used to burn readers body, and so all of these together. I think solidified that he must upset the fire that Michael Adele
LISA gasoline found on his shoes met nothin and that he and his friends would often set fires for bud. We all did it. It was in. It was in the country, in fact, Michael totally said just hours before the murder, he had his friend Josh use gasoline to set of fire on the railroad tracks near his house before Rita, got home, go through Persistent fire, but the prosecution use added mission as another piece of evidence against Michael Corleone They argued that burn pattern on the tracks. Matched burn pattern on read out. Nothing. Electrical could have caused the fire linda dec send bow and Jonathan Petersen we're jurors the case on workers. and good for him. What they were telling us was Michael, had a problem with burning and there he was the only person it could have done this. The jurors never heard about Michael's power.
Comes at school and that threat to his mother, but a whit yes testify. about a disagreement that Michael have with his mother weeks before the murder, was over money and he sat licking a lighter afterwards. It happened, but not in the way that the state betrayed. I was workin the wheel on the water that you weren't, threatening your mother with that and there was something even more damaging the prosecution claim that Michael had actually confessed to the crime during a suicide attempt at a juvenile detail, center. Exactly one month after the murder, three witnesses who work there wrote in reports that Michael said I haven't cared since I killed my mom, but Michael says. that's not what he said when they as to why you are trying to kill yourself. You say he said what, as a cuban on it's the difference
of one word, but that one word carried along. of wage and the jury would never hear from Michael, because when it was the debate is turn he didn't take the stand today is certainly resemblance to ninety eight and leave the jury with even more unanswered questions was the fact that they were told that josh see. Other boy now said knight had been granted immunity. I kept waiting thing im. Ok, you will feel he's been given. Immunity of them he's got to have something to offer, but jury never saw or heard from Josh at all. He was in called to the stand They were never shown. His video statement, Michael sisters, also work called,
I never really hurt anybody in his defence. Say Michael didn't do this. Instead, the defence hinges case on the lack of direct evidence, no murder weapon had been found and, despite the violence of the attack, Michael had no injuries and no blood. On his clothing, after three days of testimony the case when the jury to hold someone's life in your hand of you ever done. It's not applies a thing to do I wanted to get it right. but Linda Jonathan say they were left with. So many questions too many questions and they fell pressure by other members of the jury. I thank everybody. Finally, just got to mean just like we're. You go home and they now it's like the. you're ready go home and his kids are ready to go to prison
After more than four hours the jury filed into the court room with their verdict guilty of can degree murder. I wept why, because it what's wrong, Michael was sentenced to life in prison and was wrongly walls Nevertheless, we would happen. Michael would spend zennor Missouri prison before a new team of lawyers will take his case and make it their mission to turn it around. The state essentially never really had any case against this kid, but the case that they even did have back at trial has been.
indisputably proven false. What do you make of the evidence used to convict Michael chat now and facebook and twitter apartments? Dot com has helped millions of renters find their perfect places and the beauty is there all different. None of us are the same. So why should our homes be some They want hardwood floors, someone may say carpet all the way questionable call, but haiti to their own some may want to Dormann. Others may say I can open the door myself. Apartments dot com has all The right tools to help you find the place. That's uniquely perfect for you sort through and filter list. by amenities and make sure you never miss out with their instant alert option, with more than one million available units for rent you're sure to find the place. That's right for you, so whether you're looking for a place with a basement
yard. A pool or everything in between apartments dot com has got. You covered visit apartments, dot com, the place to find a place at Carvana. We're in the business of driving you happy and with the widest selection of used cars under twenty thousand dollars to a bound to find a car that'll put a smile on your face. Carvana gives you control by letting you customize your down and monthly payments. You can browse tens of thousands of cars online to find one within your budget and you won't get surprised with any bogus fees. Visit, karbala dot com or download the app to shop for a vehicle Carvana will drive. You happy Availability may vary by market to Michael foley was, was convicted and sentence delight at the age of eighteen. He was to the Missouri state penitentiary, once called the bloodiest forty seven acres in amerika,
being so young how the target gonna fight my first day. There is withdrawn rating michael says he became desperate for some sense of safety became a scan. Her joy, known as where you got there tat. Is there was something that I feel like I knew due to survive, saw the weather for you It's the way the mom raise me I just didn't fit in Michael says. He longed to prove his innocence and get out. Prison. He needed to hire a lawyer, so he says he asked his dad for help. Did he know? So? How did you keep up any help at all? I didn't for a few years, I just her when I drama love myself, I was looking for drugs. I was just self medicating
That's the way things were until Michael finally found something they gave him hope. Five years after his conviction, he wrote a letter to the mid west innocence project and they agreed to take. It in case. The organization worked on it for years and eventually attorneys tricia bush. Now megan, crane and mark amazon became involved mike was convicted because he was a kid pure and simple. They said he wasn't emotional enough trauma, doesn't look like people think it should look like the trisha, megan and Martin picked apart the case against Michael. They say it was based on bad science. Group started with the prosecution's claim that an accelerant was used to set the fire. That killed
now, when the fire investigator deigned to the scene, they immediately did determined. It was a fuel third fire based on just visual patterns, just based on looking at the scene which, at the time violated gold standards of fire investigation. There has to be lab testing control sample taken there and lab testing was dinah carpet samples threaten the crime scene. No accelerate was detected. The prosecution explained that away by saying it could have burned down, but defence attorney megan crane says that suggestion is reasonable. There's no scientific basis for that being possible. Do you believe that their jerry believed that, in fact, there was an ex seller used to say
rita on fire. Absolutely the main case against Michael was that it was a gasoline fire and in order to attempt to tie my to the crime, the only physical evidence was the gasoline that the state alleged was on his shoes. But Michael's new lawyers say that Michael shoes didn't have gasoline on them. Either for crew they say a chemical use in the shoe manufacturing process was wrongly I identified as gasoline trial Even the missouri state crime lab agrees in this too It's funny ladder. Officials say it now known that solvents found in footwear, adhesives have similarities to gasolene, but that it a laid ninety nine days? This knowledge was now widely known content.
Ben alerting to the chemicals used in their shoes. Absolutely the jurors cared about the gas on their shoes. They asked to see the issues it was the nail in the coffin What about Michael's alleged confession at the juvenile detention centre, witnesses road that they heard him say I haven't cared since I killed my mom but Michael and says he said I having carried since they killed my mom same way. We talk about tunnel vision. People can hear what they want to we're talking about one word in a room where there's lots of activity happening. They havoc a kid in the detention centre that they believe has probably committed this crime right, and so that's their view of him There is one big question that remains: what about george song, sis ii?
Remember the jury was told he got. immunity and there was that videotaped statement where he told police that he woke up in the middle of the night and Michael wasn't there the wasn't anywhere else and that better now, many years after the crime, Josh is speaking publicly. For the first time thou, what he says really happened that night When a majority on the largest china forget about it. Hi, I'm lindsey, graham host of wonders, podcast american history tellers. We take you to the events times and people that shaped america and americans. Our values are struggles and our dreams in our latest union victory in the civil war and centuries of slavery and begin
the era known as reconstruction. The federal government begins the difficult task of restoring a shattered union and political, leader struggle to integrate millions of newly emancipated african americans into a racially divided society, black americans, fight for social and economic equality, but they soon and counter violence and political. Pushed back. Follow american history tellers wherever you get your pont, you can listen ad free on the. as on music or wonder YAP, everything I'll check one to want to carry out an keep homer. I'm an address the finger and entrepreneur and of our development as the main view not upheld How many occupations over the years that my bans lovingly macneil me kiki, keep a bad palmer and trust me. I gave a vague love, but if you ask me, I'm just getting started and there's so much. I still want to do so. I decided I want to be a pot castles. I'm proud, introduce you to the baby. This is: keep calm, pockets, I'm putting my friends family and some of the deepest experts in the hot seat to ask them questions that have been burning in mamma,
am a former child stars, be if they weren't actors. Parabolas thick arms is only banned. Only that I want to know, though, as my mum about it. These are the questions that keep me up at night, but I'm taking these questions out of my head and I'm bringing them to you because on baby this is kiki. Palmer no topic is off limits, follow baby the skip home or wherever you get your podcast pay. Prime members, you can listen early and app free on amazon download the zalm use the cap today don't hurt again just move along with it but I mean it's Still it's always there now Sound sis ii is now thirty. Nine years old,
He says he's ever been quite the same since he woke up from that sleep over Michael's at the age of fifteen and himself in the middle of a murder investigation. He says he was questioned by police repeatedly for hours at a time I tell him something Would be like? No, that's not what happened. This is what happened. I remember telling my so that keeps hen suddenly nor from telling the truth anymore. But the truth Josh says is that now paying out of the ordinary happened on that night in question? I a normal the night. It's been very good. About that video tapes statement where Josh told police eddie woke up in them. of the night and michael: wasn't there, no
it wasn't anywhere else in that better. I don't remember ever saying that, and I feel like if I said that, then that was that'd be at a weak point or something Michael's attorney They say they ve seen this all too often in interrogations. What we see in dry. his interrogation is the result of hours and hours of interrogation and every other time. He has never ever said that that was what happened in a deposition right before Michael went on trial. Josh said that he never sat up from where he was sleeping on the floor, and that is not that I did not see I'm in is bad. It's I couldn't see him in his bed. There's no way I can see river, that's on top of the bed to. Why did Josh take that immunity deal I just wanted it because I knew there was gonna china pin it on me or Bernie
was like well. If they give me immunity, then maybe I don't have anything to worry about. You know. Michael's lawyers said the prosecution was likely trying to get Josh to flip on Michael and the fact they didn't even put josh on the stand, says it all. They didn't colin because it wasn't going to go well for them. He had nothing helpful to say for the state. Why didn't the defense called Josh? That's a great question erin and there's a lot of great questions about what the defense didn't do and who they didn't. Call Michael's trial attorney was a public defender back then in a court affidavit. He admits that Michael's case was the first homicide case that he had tried on his own and that today he was. Handle his representation of michael differently. Michael's new legal team was committed to getting him out of prison. They filed court document suggesting an alternative, suspect, Michael's, father, edward
Colleagues, I believe he is responsible for what happened one, if that's true, that means Michael's own father, stood by and let his son take the fall for murder that he was behind, I go sisters say their father was furious over the financial terms of the divorce. A judge have finalize them just bored as before the murder she got half of his retirement. and maintenance child support. ex alimony in the one. Thing. I remember about growing up with our Is you don't mess with his money? Is don't do it He had out versed in the court
so you'll never live to see a diamond that money police did interview, edward believe after the murder he had an alibi. He was home more than eighty miles away at the time of the murder, but Michael's defend seem says, invested. haters didn't look hard enough. They didn't at all investigate the possibility that perhaps I did this with someone else and Michael says he believes his dad did arranged the murder and how To help our John tomorrow mama johnny is johnny poorly edwards, cousin Michael's legal team identify witnesses. who plays johnny near the crime scene on the morning of the murder, justice first responders were arriving. Twelve I'd heard firing Emma some were coming up. The road or nom approaches, railroad tracks, Johnny boy.
Walkin emerald branch. Larry Lee is one of those witnesses. He's known johnny four years as he's a walking up to my truck. He asked me if I argued Rita you should from my heel. No one knew what about a week later: Larry's wife, carol and says johnny came to their door and it was like it's a clock in the morning. He said I need no You know about readers, death men we are doing our own investigation and we You were up at the store talking about it and I said johnny, I don't know nothing now we need,
What do you know? He said, and I said you know I think it's time for you to go where you scared. I was a little bit tat. The two of you talk to investigators about this. No, we think back now aim we wish we would have If he had, I knew anything either memorial, but you know. another man places. Johnny police trot near the same spot. That Larry lay says, ran into Johnny. On the morning of the murder and an affidavit filed by Michael's team, the man says he saw the truck justice emerged see. Vehicles were coming down. The road former investigate. Tell me now says she doesn't remember hearing the johnny believe habit. Seen that morning, but she does recalls something that happened in the days after the murder. Once a crime scene have been released
Somebody came in to the sheriffs department and said that they had found a tire on earth tar tool or something in the closet whose closet, Michael's closet police records, show the person you ve found that tired tool was johnny police. Could you miss down in your first search. No, are you absolutely I'm positive? I did not miss tat if it wasn't there when you search. What does that mean that somebody placed at their tammy went and retrieve the tired tool for Michael's closet? It was later ruled
out as the murder weapon he will leave that tire iron was put in your closet to set you up. How do johnny and ever believe didn't respond to our request for an interview neither has been charged in that case. It's been years since Michael and his sisters have spoken to their father, but they say they did ask him whether he had anything to do with their mothers murder and he denied it. It's not our our job and it's not our focus to say who who did commit this crime, but what we do know is it was not Michael polly and while Michael's lawyers were true to prove that pays pace would take a turn in the world and the result as they were gone.
Taken in depth, look at the case of forty eight hours, dot com, it's hard, it's real hot, here in misery to get these convictions overturned, it's a battle. I don't know. Michael's legal team was shut down by appeals courts at every turn. It is a constant fight with, and you don't goliath, really is what it feels like. Despite the let downs, Michael and his sisters kept up hope that one day he would be free and in twenty twenty one there was an unexpected development, a bill passed in Missouri, giving you in all offenders convicted of serious crimes. A second chance he Amelia brought her michael, went before the parole board.
ask him for his release or moldova, not all missus wadman. And this is: why should we I, it worked on employment policy Twenty twenty two million and crystal brought friends and family. We went in with any change of close to them. Jefferson city correctional centre? It was a really great day, the dream come true, really on that day, Michael pole, leader, walked out of prison incursion
just fourteen years old, who is now thirty eight, my lord let alone and see all the laws on ice, myself wondering what we like me out here and at this moment and had finally comes bruises, is us yeah, I'm free michael says he felt his manners were present when a bird flew by overhead- she's, always in my thoughts users. In my mind and everything I do. everything that a process of days is guided by her michael left, pray. That day, during one of the things he enjoyed most before he went at once occupied road from the border to the rural drugs leave in the same way that I came in here right applies. It doesn't really matter
Well good, does by road, world well, following his release. Michael moved in with it Sister Melanie the reading room. He started getting those reminders of prison. His tattoos covered up with this new art. He also found job as a carpenter and got his drivers license. You're now out is that enough? not enough, because the use sit right. Now you are a convicted phelan on parole. You have a criminal record that says you killed. Your mother, Michael
once the clear his name, and it just might happen because Josh hedge court, the current prosecutor in the county, where the murder took place as filed, emotion, ass, asking for Michael's conviction to be over turned to me all always comes back to the science. Hedged corinth agrees with Michael's attorneys that this scientific evidence used to convict Michael, is problematic, so I dont believe that Michael receive a fair trial. I can't say that the prosecutor at the time knew what he was putting on was false. Adjust shouldn't have been presented. Could you re try Michael paulie for the murder of his mother, based on the evidence you have today and the evidence I have today. I dont believe I would file this case, but while the local prosecutor believes Michael's, conviction should be thrown out, another pet like official Missouri attorney general Eric Schmidt, is fighting it and every
duration misery, the attorney general fights that, because they say we have to respect honour and protect the verdict of these jurors. Will that goes out the window when the jurors themselves want this verdict overturned in sworn affidavits five years have questioned whether michael got a fair trial including Jonathan, pieterzen and Linda dickerson, bow, I do not believe that Michael polyte killed his mother, but I dont know how to fix it. The attorney general's office didn't reply to our request for comment, but in a court filing they say that Michael cannot meet the standard for actual innocence, and the age has argued that the evidence against johnny and edward polyte would have been in a miserable a trial. Michael hopes that a judge will here
the case and decide to overturn his conviction, but in the meantime, prosecutor josh hedge court, as revealed to us that the local sheriffs department has reopened the investigation. Into readers murder. We want to do the right thing if someone else this we want to know that, even if its new evidence that it was Michael, neither hedge, fourth, nor the local sheriff would comment on the specifics of the investigation, including whether Johnny lead or edward police are persons of interests, about four vernon, his family, everything you have to go through. Bernie lost his whole child, Josh son, says, hasn't seen Michael police, since they were kids, but they hoped one day reunite the needed- sleep over and its aftermath has haunted josh all these years.
What would you say to him? I'm sorry, and he didn't do anything wrong. Inventory signatory, not far from where the murder took place. Readers truck has said all these years. It's gone and jars Some are, I remember her family says they have. Onto it, because it's one of the only things they have left her. That's our strong support as long they help to fix it up and get it right. Again we're on justice for I believe that one day we're going justice worried the
she just close it on they forced themselves in with nuts. They take her by force a hooded me as soon as I went into the van a deputy chases them down. I opened the rear door of the van scared to jump back and I shut the door. Hours saturday, on CBS and streaming on paramount plus hey Brian first you can listen to the forty eight hours podcast ad free on amazon, music download. The amazon music ab today or you can listen ad free with wondering, plus an apple pie. Gas before you go, tell us about yourself by completing a short survey at wondering dog com, sledge survey.
Transcript generated on 2023-07-13.