In many circles, Angela Duckworth’s name has become synonymous with the word grit, this elusive trait that fuels the sustained action-taking in the face of relentless adversity that leads to big achievements. Her book Grit: The Power of Passion and Perseverance was a No. 1 New York Times bestseller, and Duckworth is founder and C.E.O. of Character Lab, a nonprofit that uses psychological science to help children thrive.
She is also the Christopher H. Browne Distinguished Professor of Psychology at the University of Pennsylvania, faculty co-director of the Penn-Wharton Behavior Change for Good Initiative, and faculty co-director of Wharton People Analytics. A 2013 MacArthur Fellow, Angela has advised the White House, the World Bank, NBA and NFL teams, and Fortune 500 C.E.O.’s, and her TED talk is among the most-viewed of all time. And, she now also co-hosts the new podcast 'No Stupid Questions' with Stephen Dubner of Freakonomics.
You can find Angela Duckworth at:
Website : https://angeladuckworth.com/
No Stupid Questions Podcast : https://freakonomics.com/nsq/
-------------
Have you discovered your Sparketype yet? Take the Sparketype Assessment™ now. IT’S FREE (https://www.goodlifeproject.com/sparketypes/) and takes about 7-minutes to complete. At a minimum, it’ll open your eyes in a big way. It also just might change your life.
If you enjoyed the show, please share it with a friend. Thank you to our super cool brand partners. If you like the show, please support them - they help make the podcast possible.
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
This is an unofficial transcript meant for reference. Accuracy is not guaranteed.
Many circles. Angela Duckworth name has become synonymous with the word grit that elusive state
or trade or, as you will hear her describe it tendency that fuels the sustained action taking in the face of relentless adversity over an extended period of time that lee
to extraordinary achievement and outcomes her book grit, the power
of passion and perseverance was a long running number one year ties best seller and expanding her fascination with human flourishing beyond the topic of grit and also deepening into her love of children. Duckworth founded and is the ceo of character lab a nonprofit that uses psychological science is to help children thrive. She's. Also that christopher h brown distinguish professor of psychology at the university of pennsylvania factor.
co. Director of the pen, wharton behavior change, forget initiative, and fact
he could director of wharton people analytics a twenty thirteen make arthur. Fellow Angela has advice:
as the white house, the world bank nba nfl teams and fortune five hundred see egos and her ted talk is among the most viewed of all times, and she is now the co host of deep
had caused no stupid questions with stephen governor of economics, fuelling. All of this is a relentless curiosity about people why they do what they do and how to help them. Do it better, bundled with a deep desire to make a real difference in people's lives. We explore all this intimidated. Conversation so excited to share with you on Jonathan fields, and this is good life project
as a I even work where it is creativity, come from. What's the secret to living longer, ted radio, our explores the biggest questions with some of the world's greatest thinkers, they will surprise challenge and even change. You wasn't a and b shares ted radio, our wherever you get your PA guests.
so the ten percent happier podcast has one guiding philosophy. Happiness is a skill that you can learn. So why not embrace it? It's hosted by dan Harris a journalist who had a panic attack on national television and then send out on this journey of transformation and he's now on a quest to help. Others also achieve peace and happiness, and every week Dan taught you top scientists meditation teachers. Even the odd celebrity in wide ranging conversations at explore topic, psych productivity, anxiety and lightness, psychedelic and relationships. The interviews cover everyone from bernay brown to cerebral less to sam Harrison more. I love learning from his questions and experiences and incredible guess think of listening to ten percent happier as a work out. For your mind, fine ten percent happier where every listen to pot casts
good law project is supported by the economists, so the world seems to be moving faster than ever: climate economics, politics, ai and culture. Wherever you look, events are unfolding at a rapid pace and it's hard to stay on top of it, which is why I love that now, for the first time, you can get a one month, free trial of the economist, so you won't miss a thing I have literally been reading the economist I want to say for decades. I love that it covers more than just economics and finances you'll find coverage on topics from politics to science, to technology, even arts and the environment. The economist offers this global perspective with really incredible clarity and deeper analysis, so you can dive into specific issues or catch up on current events, I was just checking out this article on the changing landscape of tech, jobs for recent computer science grads and how everything is changing so fast. It was a real eye opener and with the economists free trial, you'll get access to in depth independent coverage of world events through podcasts, webinars and expert analysis. As soon as you sign up, if you're interested in subjects like this go to economist dot com, slash project for full access to the topics that matter to you, an original analysis as events unfold, that's economist, dot, com, slash project or just click. The link in the show notes to start your one month, free trial with the economists today, because the world won't wait and want to dive in
Do you? Because you are in the context of all of this, there is so much incredible work that you have done so much work that you're doing and arm and eventually want to get to the broadcast that you ve been rocking out this year as well. You ve built this.
Stunning career as a researcher and an educator a lot of it focused around grit and expanding out into a broader character traits
It sounds like the sort of education has been a part of your ethos from the earliest days. It was sort of like something that was drummed into you and part of the culture of your family as well yeah. I think education
you know it's an efficient water, you're you're, not even
consciously aware of how important education is because, like everyone, you know things, education is important and then you and then you realize, like oh you know, there is there's something like unusual about this emphasis. When you, you know, leave your family in you. You know you go experience. Other other influences, but I
is it my my devotion to education.
Now is maybe less from my family. Saying like it's important, you know, education is, is the issue
waiter do anything in life. I think I think I really like kids so when I was in high school-
I too very little bed and do the rise in college. I really like I spent, I think,
be spent more time with care
it's in the neighborhood is a tutor as big sister as organizing forgot than night than I did in the classroom. So I think I just you know kids agree and smarter than
in their nicer than us in their more energetic
yeah I mean have you ever thought yourself like what is about the quality of being a child that so draws you to them? You know the area
our kinetic right, if you're around kids, like it's just its palpable
like they, just maybe there might
hungary or better but they're, just kind of
bouncing off the walls with energy, and I don't just mean three year olds right and the like fifteen year olds, like
senior year there, just the color of cheese they've got like
like a life force, and I find that to be like,
really revitalizing right, Frida, meaning life right like it. If you feel energized and
and I do think there is like a
purity like they're. Just I mean I really do think they're like smarter nicer than
then we are in so many ways right like that. There is a real kind of authentic.
the especially young, kids, of course right who it's like
this does not a lot of
layering of strategy,
it's cetera. So so I dunno, I I've really enjoyed them from from that perspective. Also, when I was a freshman in college, you know like most eighteen year olds are figuring out what to do,
during one of experimenting- and I remember I volunteered both as
the tutor and also as a laker
who would go visit people in the locals, nursing home and was publicly funded nursing home and I got assigned to patients
and I would go every week and six. It was because they were people who didn't have a living family or these little family, good visitor,
and I remember having these like two experiences like tutoring like
nine year old and
visiting
eighty five year olds and
in the same neighborhood, and
these are both like terrible things
but I guess the other reason I'm drawing to education. You know, in addition to maybe my family culture
in addition to like liking, kids, because their awesome is that
If you really want to make the world a better place, there just seems to be a kind of logic of like war. This kid needs
no more than what they're getting maybe-
since they are at the beginning of their lives like this is
good time, to try to invest
so just in some sense, I hadn't
intuition, that enough
to be very like like
if you want to make the world a better place like how could you not like help start with kids? No, I love that. I mean I mean it's, it's curious. I love the idea of bouncing between relate the nine year old and then you're dramatically
fast forward that near the person who is close to ninety and this yet
there are probably some really fascinating similarities between those two age groups in our level of openness and curiosity, a level of I feel like it
late there's. It there's this window where we
or to centre our lives and our thoughts and expression.
that's almost eight when you catch people before that in it, it's a different issues,
into the human condition and then, when you, when you step into
lies in their late eighties, they're, probably
We were one make assumptions, but I'm getting a lot of people will be at the point where you kind of like you know. I got nothin to
just, is what it is. And here with you, you know
nor had observed our destiny? I mean you know. I see that the two women that I was visiting were not especially
to explore. Heads us was tried to convince the lives of these. I didn't do very good.
Bitch leader in my life, I think it was in my
thirty's, or maybe my maybe it was my thirty's us talking to my friend Adam grant, is also psychologist. Monsieur you know Adam many,
I daresay most people I interact with like no him or know of him, so I called him and I said, we're both tenure
as professors and we're very blessed
trying to make a rank ordered list of like the problems in the world that I should work on. You know in order of importance like if you done that, like what do you think he said
no. I thought about that
the end of the day, I realise that is very difficult to rapporteur, like climate change. Compare,
to funding reform in education or elections, were it's it's very difficult to make that list.
Sure that's the right list, any
behind these
whose are all like saw above threshold, maybe should make the list based on like what
you get energy from him, what you're good at and, I think,
there are some social problems which you could argue are more urgent than others. But there are so many that really
buff threshold. I thought that was great advice and I dont think that
but I work on is necessarily more important than what other people work on, but they get above threshold to sail
hey baby psychological sites can do something to helping our kids thrive and for me as it as a as an individual, for whatever reason, even more
in food I find,
Human nature, to be endlessly fascinating,
it's it's funny, because I I have noticed how I do a lot of research whenever, if I sit down before every conversation- and I have
quick note. I wrote down relentless curiosity in the way that shows up when you're being interviewed as you take over the interview. Very often, I know it's like asking questions. Why did you do right and I and I'm like I'll, be listening to all of a sudden, I'm like wait a minute she's asking all the questions
if you're so so yeah. I usually like apologize to the interviewer afterwards
It's alright said to like it just had to know. I wanted to know what you were thinking yeah, but I think his ethics as you beautiful right, because it shows that somehow you have found a way to channel so much of your energy into something that
people are curious about, but also even when the context,
supposed to beat them asking of you.
You are so curious just about the current interaction that your own about the human being your conversation with that, it's almost like you can't help yourself,
Have this child like curiosity, about
going on in the mind and a life experience of the person that you are momentarily in conversation with
I do feel like one of the great joys in life is to have to feel like the way you were when you were a kid and you're curious about somebody you just like to know, and it was in a way like a need or a yearning which sounds negative but but like it's, it's great right, like you're, just quote, unquote dying to know right. I
often feel like that I've never met somebody that didn't interest to me.
and when I think about what I read about like, like you said
Oh, you know some interest in food. True right,
do read a lot about food, but I'm not reading actually like the books about like me.
like astronomy. Unlike what really happens when you breeze something unnaturally reading like memoirs about food, you know, like I'm, reading,
kay fisher and I'm I'm like reading,
those stories of like the people. You know why do people do that, like a white like so so the
human dimension of
anything that is happening is, is invariably what interests me one
husband? I bought a house recently with moved sidewalks.
philadelphia and
the real ter would just you know, find it hysterical that when he would
me to a new home. Instead,
I I like to think
about the moulding or the electrical
some. I was always asking these questions like owen and why
did they want to move out of this, but then so they ve three.
Children's. How old are they like what you know? Why do you think that they
cited to go into that profession and the real just like,
I don't know, but I don't know that it's relevant to buying a house, but it is exactly where my mind goes. Yeah I mean it's almost like this childlike state of wonder where it's just about a fierce curiosity about everything, and everyone do you think everyone's like that, though, like just to you know, do my thing
the question I put to you relate the like. Other people do
Do you know in your experience and like? Do you think there people who are less
You aren't, as in some ways I feel like, is in every
you're doing this. All the time
I actually don't think so, and
here's. Why is that? So
we have actually been doing sort of. My research for a couple of years had developed a set of archetypes had an assessment that looks at the primary
fibers of work of effort, cross spectrum, people and so on
it is our entire, with without spectator categorized as the maiden, which is basically a either broad based.
deep dive fascination a love of learning your problem line. Up with that, and I like the vs strengths and we ve got about tat,
million people who been through the assessment, this monsieur some serious data and
maidens or people who are driven by curiosity or fascination or absolutely the most prevalent of the archetypes them
willing to invest effort in pursuing that curiosity, fascination? They should
it's anywhere between twenty five and thirty percent of the population or the people who taking the assessment
there are also other people and
their drivers that
seem to be much less interested in learning and much more interested in doing particular things
It's almost like have
to stop that to learn
something or go deep into a curiosity or fascination, is more than annoyance. It takes them away from this other thing, and I might
and my lands is that we are in
for a hammer the world? Is it now
and that those who are that are the main events cannot conceive of any one else approaching the world similar to them, just like any other orient
no wiring or any policy. I take it for granted. You're, like isn't everybody right, this kind of hammer like aren't, aren't
things, I see this kind of now.
you know my dad is to say their thinkers doors and charmers, and he wanted to make
extinction. First of all, between thinking and doing which you just empty
eyes, and then he said you know the people who really get
he's done or thinkers anders
really get things done, or thinkers doors and charmers anyway, that
my dad's taxonomy of the universe, and I do think that I am
times like a very curious person. I'm also vary
doing or did I took the myers
eggs- personality indicator like
mbt. I guess Myers briggs type indicator
a whole other conversation, because most reason
Psychologists don't put a lot of
How can it, but I do remember, taking it in
getting like zero for thinking and the maximum score for feeling and the the test
you're coming over in saying like, I think I think you sauce
with this wrong, and then it was returning
I know you got a zero for the actual mackenzie consulted at the time which the worrisome to my colleagues but yeah, I think, there's a part of me to survive.
curious, especially that unita nitrates, but everything actually don't know that
I don't know than anybody's curious about everything, except for young children. I'm
not trees about politics like I'm, not curious about, like lots of
Wouldn't issues deeply curious about human nature and I am a door like there is a the like if
I'm on vacation by like day
three just like dying to do
something that feels like a progression to me. What I mean
mike usa, gas is is, and what is the aim
underneath the doing you now do
to achieve what are doing at which currently loops has, to a certain extent, to add one of this. The topics that you have studied for awhile
have time now, which is this thing in capital g grit
were really talk about when, when you zoom the ones out- and you look at people who have achieved stunning things across a number of different domains and very often in the face of great adversity over an extended period of time and you
Bryce this crushing like what is it? What is it? What is the thing that
sting wishes them from other people and
and you identified hissing, which you would you call great candied, deconstruct that for me a little bit yeah
define grit as
the combination of law
the term passion and
long term, perseverance
with the emphasis on long term by the way? So I'm just going to say what I think about these things. I think, by the way, these are words- and you know nobody-
owens any of the words in the english or any other language, so I am not saying that other people he uses words are wrong or you know they are, and I'm not
that this is the best way but did to clarify,
When I say long term I mean in adulthood really over years.
decades to to really have a abiding sense of doing something? That's really important to you that you
does that you are not border, as you know, after like a year or two or three or four or five or six and then proceed
iran's. As you know, the more obvious part of the I think like working incredibly hard, even one,
is wrong and then
being resilient when things are wrong, so it
how about
time on task like high quality, high quantity engagement.
he is probably the final common path to any.
in achievement and grit
is this ten
see by the way. Thank you,
change your grants, it's not to say a fixed tendency, but attendants
he to stick with things and to keep.
pursuing them. You know not not a different thing every every few years and edges,
work really hard at it? So so, when I
What's the last stance which I feel it goes the last person to watch the last dance and he just finished that that's the reason I'm just you know like everybody else, I was glued to the screen. How could you not
But when you look at liquor,
the jordan Orleans yvonne? You know like it's it's
credible? How much
high quality consistent high quantity energy are, they devoted
aircraft you know not over year, not overdo is really over decades and- and I think that is why these people are so great
to have a discussion about talent to, but I think that's that
Grit is in and that's why I study.
Met yet the global private aviation leader is known for personalizing every detail of your travels because not yet standard is not just to meet their definition of perfection. It's to exceed yours discover more at net jets, dot com.
The project is supported by noon. So it's that time of the year, where a lot of folks start to think about their fitness goals, getting their bodies moving myself included. I actually recently started paying a lot more attention to how I was fueling, my body and also really came to realize that I was carrying a lot of inflammation in my body and potential disease risk in the form of weight. So I wanted an intelligent and sustainable and supportive way to increase my health, lose the weight and inflammation and just feel better and noom is just a great solution for this one that I have turned to numerous times over the years to help me accomplish wellness and when it makes sense, weight management goals as well. So noone uses science and personalization, so you cannot just intelligently manage weight for the long term, but also really learn from their psychology based approach that helps you build better habits and behaviors that are easier to maintain and the best part you decide how newman fits into your life, not the other way around, based on a sample of four thousand two hundred and seventy two numerous ninety eight per cent say: noom helps change their habits and behaviors for good, and that is because noone actually helps you understand the science behind your choices and why you have certain cravings. So if you feel like you've been lacking the knowledge to make the changes, you want to see, try out noom, so you can start making informed choices and start to really change the way that you think about weight, loss and weight management and wellbeing. Take the first step and sign up for your trial today at noon: dot: com, that's n, o o m dot com to sign up for your trial today or just click. The link in the show notes,
let right it is supported by I heard, so I am always looking for new ways to get more nutrients into my daily routine to promote really all around better. Well being and recently I have discovered- I urge a one- stop shop that offers the best curated selection of wellness products at incredible values. Then everything from vitamins and sports supplements to bath products can care and make up. I had so much fun, exploring their website and finding things had a really wanted, like thorns, calcium, magnesium, melick capsules and vitamin d three k to both of which support, bone and muscle health and immune function. I urge that just made it so easy to find what I need, because you can search by category or even wellness, concern and best of all, I feel safe, knowing that every product is tested, verified and sold directly by. I urge so it's time to get your health in check with. I urge our listeners get twenty two percent off your first order. When you use code good life at I urge dot com. That's twenty! Two percent off your first order at I h: e r b, dot com, promo code, good life or just click. The link in the show notes and use a promo code. Good life choose. I urge, because, while miss matters.
yeah, I mean fascinate, the use of our tendency, which I'm curious about and as I've learned about grid over the years looked at your work looked at at some of the other commentary around it and just looked at the the broader field of positives,
They social science. I have been curious how great
he gets describe. The in my mind I keep looking between. Is this state? Is it a trait use the word tendency and they must pay
the curiosity for me is that if you view
a trade which I've heard it spoken about
First time is in.
Underlying. That is the assumption that it's not changeable, if you use it as a state or tendency will then may,
It opens the door to this being a train of all things, something which is liable overtime. Some I'm curious were where
fallen there. So if I could try to communicate something that is
true and very nuanced, then I will do a victory dance after this kind.
because I think it's very hard to understand, but I'm gonna try and and its
it's the idea that any trade is a distribution of states, so it's not the grit is a trade war estate. It's that, when I say a tendency, I,
in that the figure really ready person it. What it means is that.
Very often if you like, dropped into the middle of their life and some
like children there doing very often they would be in the state of like passionate pursuit of
thing that their working very hard. If you take a very low grit person,
more often than you drop into their life in lebanon,
right now like. Are they doing something with passion and perseverance? They ve been working on for years like that? That would happen less often
But any human being has it,
jewish, and so, if you say like. Oh Michael Jordan, was really ready. You know he's a
extremely you'd be like you could drop in on almost any moment in his life right, and you could make a good bet that he was like thinking about basketball and working to improve
and you know exhibiting eyes
would be, however, though, that, like you, know you drop in and and there's a day
an hour a moment where he's doing like something totally random and it. But I think the idea that treats
your strengths are tendencies and people have died.
provisions by the way. This is hard to explain to a general audience without knowing a little bit about statistics whose what I
and by distribution is like, if you could,
Imagine in your minds, I like a little graph rate like you.
see, the distribution means like. Where are you on average? Where are you sometimes? Where are you? You know rarely like any
The idea is that I think grit is a treat
since that people differ on their distributions, but
buddy differs within themselves right, so so people have the capacity
even if there are really high grip person to
usually be low grit, and I think that is
Why does too, you know
since I'm already in this like quagmire.
Of complexity, which is, I think, actually what human nature really is. A very complex human nature cannot be communicated in a ted talk. I think I think that is why
you'd, like your contacts matter so much rate, so you can be
the greedy person and your coaches just toxic or europe
company. Is toxic and you're really a passionate
doing person, but you ve,
opportunities to do like learn.
to develop like that. That will also influence. You know whether you are in a state of great so so that is
no, the fuller picture of grit, which I have struggled to communicate because it's hard right, like I think it's hard to understand
things that treats and states are an opposite or like it's either traders, but that
all humankind. Actually, I will say this end
serious personality psychologists,
we'll just like, of course, all tendencies, all the strength and the visa. You know what
would mean to be, accorded equal, grateful person or, like you know, curious
he's a signature strike. What it really means is that if somebody sampled your life, that your
provision would be all kind of like bunched up you know towards
the high curiosity end of the spectrum and that the
to look for us too, to be rare, but not exist, not non existent yeah. I'm in this fascinating to me. You know, if you think of it as a
sampling of of many moments over a long window of time and then looking at here, the the distribution, then it also makes me curious about. Well,
he's doing the sampling and how are they actually view
in the context of what allows somebody to expressly sings verses. What doesn't
If you look at one person in life, who has simply by
the nature of their circumstances. A lot of opportunity to do this thing to express it in an unencumbered way, with a lot of resources versus somebody else who comes out
the very different place, and maybe remains in those circumstances, for four decades or for life and would lie
to express his identical things, but because
as of constraints and circumstances just doesn't have the opportunity of tourism
how you take that into account when you're sampling those moments and figuring out how these two people are different in their expression, so let's make it distant
in between what theoretically is probably true and like how you would ever actually do it think it's really important to do that, because when I say that, like oh people, are these distributions- and imagine this like thought, experiment that you could like parachute into their life and then see what
doing and then you could like. That's not actually what happens right because of its very hard to do
so in theory, though, I just will stay
by and I could like literally ask any trained people.
psychologists
but in and by the way the psychologist, whose really pioneers you're, who like put in
two. It knows Wolfensohn any causing the density distribution model
for now the anyway all very hard to communicate, but but it's not
controversial it's like every. I think, every
serious psychologists, be like oh yeah, of course. So it's come
acts. But it's not like new or its
May not my new idea.
ok! So then you're like one who would do the sampling that, like I think that you know these are all good.
She's getting more relevant is like the part of what you were saying about.
When you observe somebody doing something are not doing something. You know you could
they, like all their highness character. Strict alone is characterised right. There's a
tradition of state in part, because your circumstances matter enormously rate iceman this.
terrible summer my parents owned this
tiny little like needlepoint canvas company, that
You know my mom would get it
like canvas is shipped in from taiwan, and they all had the made in taiwan sticker on them, which was some you know, require
mate for customs and then my job for the whole summer was to take the stickers these little gold,
overall stickers it said made it. I won't take them off right, which I hope was legal, but it
That's what I was asked to do, and you know,
I'm a pretty hard working person. I feel like I'm, actually pretty energetic prison. It was like
torture I mean the first
hour of the day. I was going,
crazy, already and so exhausted and end, and I think that's
ample like how your situation is going to
change like your behaviour, not because you're like a low curiosity person or your low energy per cent or your irritable, percinet you're. Now at that
the spectrum in your distribution you're on the lower end of curiosity for you, because you are in a situation that doesn't give you be afforded to like be at your best and
I think the recent conversations and country about equity.
and about racism, and I
anne and more are are enough in a very
important way, like shining a light on like how uneven and how
spirit. People's opportunities really are, I think, that's enough.
Dealing with positive psychology and and the kinds of things that I worked, because you don't want to make what the psychologist that I
No, we call the fundamental attribution error, which is
observer behaviour,
tribute it entirely to the persons tendencies and not taken into account.
contact situation,
the opportunity obstacles that are outside of the individual
yeah I mean that makes a lot of sense to me.
And I do feel it. The conversation is happening in this country now touches into that in a lot of different ways. Beyond the the this general attribution air
the curious about house or the notion of survivor bias effects when you're,
you're looking at who is ready and if you take somebody who
achieves this incredible thing. You know, through perseverance and passion and credible resilient over a long period of time through adversity, and they reach
is neo capital as successful as we often we were being hunted
call them like a greedy person, but you take somebody
the exact same thing:
And then
They either fail or become destroyed along the way and in height I, you know, we popular culture will then
look at that person and not call them ready or successful, but rather Eric
and or delusional
so I wonder how this idea observe survivor, bias, please
the conversation, if at all, yet the eye
survivor by us or its sometimes called sampling on independent variable that do its bit
good idea like if you look at all that the winner circling you're, like hey these people, have all these. You know things in common for europe,
looking at everyone and it could
that those same characteristics that are true of the people, who are you know it at the top of their careers? Could be it the same of
people who are at the bottom or the middle or whatever else you. You have a fallacy there. If you do that so
in my research I I both interview, people who are you know like olympicum medalist, but most
my public research. Actually, all my polish
search is based on law
the two nor sam
rules where you're, not just looking at the people who finished right so at west point. Four
well, if you only interview the people who generation,
ok, they're, really gritty, then you could be
going on independent variable. You could be commit
this error. But if you start out with all the cadets and they all take the great scale- and you know
of it's like symbol, but yours you're still, starting with everyone, men of the people who
You know your studying. You can look at variation on their outcomes, said that
the solution to this error and
you know. That is why I think it's important
studies that are not just like heads interviewed this
I olympic athletes ghastly it's my company just like draw these inferences as so. So that's
this sort of methodological solution,
makes sense me you're, teaching it leagues.
all of that connects at west point. I think Israel,
interesting, also, certainly, when you're taking a group,
people who are stuck together and they're all tasked with essentially working towards
the same outcome in there's a pre defined
then point and a predefined metric for success and parliament
broader curiosity, I grant also is
it shows up and how it applies when you are out in the world doing things where there
no predefined end point where more than agile process where you need to serve defined
success along the way and even decide whether you can succeed or have and if his
worth the costs of in real time as you're doing it yelling does grid apply when learning along the way is a part of them.
for six ass, I think you're right
just to. First of all, a contrast, you know really structured environment, ino sports
Like that to write, like a mean, what if you are
the very long past, to becoming will you hope, an olympic old medalist right like
It's very hard, but it's it's structured.
In a way that most
I don't have that most of us are like more like fill in the blank than multiple choice in terms of the choices are making and that's harder and in some ways I feel like it so
I would somebody pursue something for years- is that the goal must be at a level of abstraction
that- it's not like some new accomplish like in a day or weak, or you, like you,
You know when you ask people, and, and not everyone has an
Was it top level goal
that they could say like ours is my mission statement for my life and I think,
maybe one out of ten people that I've talked to like has it.
very conscious way. Even people who really greedy could sometimes it can be like
non conscious or like
You know an outsider might say like. I would think your balls this, but they might not be
haven't having it in their head. Like that, I think
whether its conscious and available to you or or less so
it is having something which you are
these were working toward an end. I think that
idea, that its higher level go in a hierarchy of goals.
Explain to me why there has to be a lot of flexibility and experimentation manner?
it's cliche almost when you, when you really get what people's top level goals are because they're so abstract. You know, like you know, be my best. You know like make the world a better place, like you know, bring out the best in others. I have a
student danny himself,
It is a former and a hell. Quarterback is now getting as phd.
you did. The masters imposes psychology programme which how I met him and his top level.
All professionally is show what's possible right. Ok, that is,
credibly, inspiring and poetic put it so abstract right. It's
particulars right, where there's so much experimentation, unlike is that going to be,
through being
a coach? Is that going to be through, like becoming a research psychologist,
how can I do that? So so I think when you are living,
or life like most of us, are living you're you're, really
I think, struggling to kind of like figure out like which path ice,
you'll think having
articulation, however, of that northstar top level. Abstract goal is held
for re, even if, like the path toward that is
something you're constantly experimenting with, and it's been
for to me, you know, I think, my top level
like logical science to help kids thrive, isn't even as abstract as as it you know is for us
people, but but just knowing that, like you know
I go on this podcast like is it you know
what would I do on Friday afternoon to me? It helps me decide, and it helps me realize, like no
thought that that not that podcast like, but maybe this one or like notion should do that on Friday afternoon. I should do this on Friday afternoon, because because, ultimately,
it's more aligned with what I care about most deeply
I guess it helps orient around the and that last here he said at the israeli what it comes down to what I care about most deeply. You know, even if you'd, if
if you don't have some predefined sense of this is exactly where I'm headed. This is exactly what you know it. It look
I got this is exactly what I'm looking to create or learner discover achieve.
to have a strong sense of this is the thing that fuels me that wake me up in the morning and am I making
progress towards that
It is why I am, I think,
use the word agile there in the world of entrepreneurship and start ups for a long time, lean was a sort of like a hot wording
another, was fascinating because-
Would the essentially refrain the idea of a start up as you like, a stored up is effectively.
A group of people in search of a business model, who you know,
and the goal was not to quote succeed here, like the guy
was to learn here like it was. It was to reiterate, as
rapidly as you can to prototype, to get feedback and
medical was just to learn and lower and lower and learn. And as long as you're learning then
you could say, I'm succeeding, even if, at the end of the day, the learning taught you this was
terrible idea, and we absolutely shouldn't do it. I think
because, when you orient around that, then I feel like
were it becomes almost more accessible, no matter what the
ecommerce or matter whether you burn through.
the seed money that was given you and realize it was a terrible idea to store where there is a great paper at of stamford been school. I just love it. It's about
success being metaphorically a journey and not a destination, and of course, you know
that's a metaphor. That's been around for a while, but they actually did these regional design experiments. We show people photographs of
road and I, like a liquor
house, or something in the distance-
the inner on one condition. Your encouraged
Think of success as the road right as the journey is path and then another condition like successes there. It's like getting there, it's like that house in the distance. That's your goal they found was you know that
relatively simple brief.
doctrine and and and metaphorical framing, actually encouraged people in actual real life. Golden
did things like exercise exercises to to stick with things
longer and to put more energy into it, and in general I think it's a healthier thing, actually just ugly,
divine yesterday as she's great, and I think she has many characterise ranking, including obviously grit, and she you know too,
about how
as early. She can remember really like shoot
one up herself right and any really. That is the idea that, like you're, never there right,
if she would say that too, like even when she retired gino,
name. The number of
things that she wanted to do that she hadn't done. So I think it is like a good way to think. Like you know what my learning right, like that, I learned something to by the way I have tried to use this during the pandemic, because this
just the most stressful year of my life of most people's lives that I know- and I am especially
left, so I'm I'm can only imagine what other people are going through, but I am trying to wake up in the morning. In addition to doing my three good things exercise and thinking of three blessings in my life, I am trying to think of at least one thing. I learned
when all these imports
elections right like oh, this happened, and that was not what I wanted and like then I tried to do that and that did not work out the way it went like that
made this mistaken. You I mean that poor judgment. I think. If I keep
back to a question of like
What did I learn? Then? It frames it. You know us, as you said like in the railway, does it does it matter that you burn through your started, like yeah
but but what what you really want to think about is like what did? I learn
I mean in that context of day to day life in content.
Start ups wherever it may be. I feel like they're just.
taking that frame. You live a better life.
because, no matter what happens now as law
as you pause because kind like reflect on it. It's kind of like you can
you can't kill, is right.
Second, the moment it may be a brutal experience and may be hard, but you know
you frame it as as you like do. I now know something that will inform how I move forward and in it in a different way. This uncertainty right now. Isn't it great that you could basically gap
can t that you win
Few say like that. I learned something today and yeah you're right and by the way truly broadcast performer
learn from their successes to write so
is very hard to learn from failure. Actually, new research
from
Psychology shows its especially hard to learn from failure, so we should praise the winds, yvonne's and Michael jordans from one from failure, but also
they learn from success. And that's
that's hard to right, because soap so often just like- oh I do know that worked out like it so anyway, having a learning mindset at all times is, I think you know a wonderful thing.
In so many ways yet
And I think it also speaks to a certain extent to um thoroughly
coach or a mentor or a guide, or somebody who steps in rio. We em had Anders ericsson studio of a while back ethical,
People know his original research, which has been missed
Turkey and Iraq,
The ten dollars now rule which is not a tent, does narrow, but the idea of this yelich deliberate practices gruelling practices. It was fascinating to me as early as car.
focus seems a lot more to be on the role of that
person who steps in and when you're in this,
process of growth and learning and struggling
importance of having somebody else alongside you who can zoom the lens out a little bit and
look at what's happening, have the wisdom and the experience to understand how to help
You move through a moment
you perceive as and move through a bulk for lack of better way of putting it. And yes,
I got less yvonne, are proof professional athletes to people the top of their game.
to do this. I wonder how often you his lens was. This is a mission. Critical piece is almost impossible to push
this place. Law
determined term and this process, if you don't find or have that person or multiple people, I wonder if, if you
you have seen or or think the same thing yeah
Andrews passed away this summer? And it's in appropriate time? I think to you no honour this life. Mainlanders really was the whole expert on road exe
and when you talk about you know,
enter a guide. You note I he wasn't high.
The way like lindsey VON scheme
but he was actually a mentor for me, and so I was able to belatedly. I guess you I wrote
gratitude letter, which I read at his memorial service.
I was able to say in that letter. You know, I am quite sure I would not be where I am today- thou,
which is exactly as you as you say. You know what what others
sir surmised, after studying experts for his whole life that people rarely
If ever truly go it alone, there are
lots of reasons why that is one that you mentioned, is the motivational one right I mean I dont know many people who are the way
I to like, you know, realise like how to put things in perspective and to give them so
If the pep talk, you know like the day, they really need it
I think for most of us. We can think like. Oh yeah, that's what my husband does or my wife does, or my peer does or my my men,
my coach, my boss,
The other reason, though wonders with one or two to talk about. Is that when you think about the practice that world class experts
its goal directed his very strategic. It's not like! Oh gee. I wonder what I should do this like two hours like its highly choreographed as well thought out.
thing in anders his experience
extremely rare that the person,
it is the performer
do all that mapping out, like you need to feel jackson to say, like
who can work on. Is that you?
a trainer who says like our aid today, we really have to work on that and I think that's really a profound point.
I would call anders
occasionally. Might I met him when I was stone graduates gothic goes like toward the you know,
if graduate school. For me- and I would call him for advice in especially when those feeling lost, which was somewhat frequent-
and- and he really did like he- he gave me it.
I couldn't just like write my journal and come up with the advice that he would give me
you tell me the like look for a salient role model and to you know to try like pop
they did. You ask me to like define
what success looked like into like think about the obstacles anyway, he'd? He, he said a lot of things that I think
able to me too,
I too, to become better what I did, and I think that is you know that
it's true, it's exactly what he was working on. You know when he passed away.
I just found it so compelling, and especially the less might you were making. Where is she
yeah part of it is about the motivation, but that the role of having somebody who
lack of a better word it is, is in possession of a different set of mental models and experiences and and the ability to reflect to you what you don't see and offer.
A frame that is just not within Europe.
sperience it added
and when he shared that I should say yeah. I never really thought about it that way, but that
me is, I think, a much much harder,
It may be more important than the short like what the l a puppy,
website of things you know, I'm the term I am I my colleague Ethan cross, might uses and psychological.
Distance right, an end.
It's so true I mean my husband, I've gotten into Appendix
routine of almost knights, and- and
We really try like to take a little walk right like a walk,
after dinner, with her
son just to like process. Our days which have usually been filled,
with small to medium sized dressers, and just you know
fruit for him to be able to tell me, like a things at went wrong, I mean I have.
Distance right. So it's it's. It's really helpful to have another human being. Who cares about you, but they didn't go to the same bad day right so they have a little perspective, but he was a really truly, as you know, I think, like kind and
Funny and fun person, and I I feel leg
I feel like. Not. Everyone also would know that right there, like over ten thousand our role which, as you as
Point out is usually misinterpreted, and then you know his mouth
the mental work, as my own adviser Marty, seligman, would say
Not many scientists can say they really discovered something important but on,
I could say that, and for all those reasons like he should be memorialize is, is a patrol appeared in every major newspaper? That's all correct,
and right and everyone
by his book. Peek at everybody should read it like. You could literally become better what you do
in a more efficient way. If you understand otters work, but he was such a good person
His wife said at his service,
that, in her very long marriage,
could not remember a single occasion when he
unkind to anyone.
So anyway, I think it's a it's a wonderful thing to be mentioning him in this conversation, no
of that and aunt em. I didn't know that you're so close him and he had played such a meaningful role and reassure eagerly tenure
at my writing letters like rhodesia worry, you were. You know a big reason why anyone would wanna know believe in my work.
Yeah. That's amazing
when at last start getting so complicated, buying a home, complicated home finance is certainly not a walk in the park. Raising kids, it's a lot, then there's insurance. What if my policy doesn't cover this or what? If I have to make a claim in the middle of the night, good news state farm is there for your? What is you can reach them? Twenty four seven file a claim on the state: far mobile, laugh or simply call your agent to ask anything. So even if life gets tricky, insurance doesn't have to be like a good neighbour states form. Is there call or go to state, formed our com for a quote today.
Hey, it's jonathan from good life project. If you are in your thirties or forties with friends too busy to join you on a vacation, you have to check out flashback the only group travel brand for solo travelers, your age, imagined dining with su mo's in japan, or basking on a private yacht in croatia. All with people like you, visit flash pack, dot com, slash podcast, you save two hundred and fifty dollars on your booking and offer only available until july. Fifteenth.
and it's itching also cause it kind of like as resume that lens out from the grid and yeah like your. You have not just been solely focus on this one thing called grid. It has been a
piece of your work, but also partly character, lad. You know it's it
looking at the other elements of the human experience of what makes us the way that we are of your beyond it
she meant, and how do we treat others knew it serve? A d
the exploration of the life of the mind and what goes on in there and all the different things that contribute to the way we bring ourselves to the world and in it, and to a certain extent,.
The way the world returns certain things to us. Do you like the way character? I do
I bet there's probably where reason for now it sounds. I think it's hokey and I think it's it
hurricanes to a time to me.
It's kind of an old tie. Me word yeah that speaks to
you a moment where
quality of humans, heart of their intellect of their service. That contribution was at the centre of life.
And I and I sometimes wonder whether that is
not so much the case. These days
and an idle like the word, because I think I.
and I'm more in the last debate, because I don't necessarily believe it's gone, but I yearn for more of its return to its beautifully said.
Yeah I've been thinking about the word lately. Well, not just lately, but also lately. I think
Aristotle used the word character in translation
Martin Luther king said intelligence and character, and these are the true cause of education. Re montessori, John dewey, like their many great thinkers who have improved.
this term. One of my favorite thinkers is jackie, pesos, who, among
Things is the mother of Jeff basin
says character is how you show up in the world, and I
I think these are the reasons I do like the word character, but I think sometimes people think like
It sounds like it
he's a tory at it. You know it sounds like you're blaming the victim like, oh, therefore, character like that's. Why they're not do so
Like any word, I guess it has its price.
and cons, but I did creed
is nonprofit cod character, lab with two educators deed.
Levin and Dominic rand, often they really like the word character. They had been very tracked it
the work of Marty seligman. Who is my adviser, graduate schools? I said anyway, I do
I think that some emphasis on you know how you feel.
up in the world and also like, as you say, like how the work
returns that and-
emphasised that, like how the world treats you is part of where you are
character. Issue
I mean so again
isn't this conversation is taken us to complexity into nuance. I I think, that's
important it's not like your characters to something you're born with. I mean you know,
The kind people come from, I think kind people come from people be
kind to you and you
where'd, you unkind, people come from lake, probably
people being unkind to that was her. So I think it's it's a new
its thing, but I ate I'm yeah, I'm proud to have a nonprofit called character
and I like it. I, like the association with the word I can see how may be loaded for some people, but also for me
and that's the way thy
frame that I have for it is past.
They have in a surly
instant, meaning and and law.
Then contribution and purpose, and things like that. It's fishing that
yeah yeah reflection, though I was recently having in conversation with a friend about d.
Experience of shame and
said. Well, you know, there's a shame that society, that's that's right away from the outside in your when you're, not living up to bob law.
And then there, just like the inner shame yeah like the anaemic,
is born with shame. You know,
there is no inner shame until it comes from the outside. It lets very interesting, yeah
and the things remain like some inner. Shame that, like it's just you know, springs at a year. Arteries and beans are something like.
It was my curiosity in early guy, I feel like. Sometimes we live
with a certain framework experience for so long
that. We almost can't imagine it not emanating from within interesting. It just feels like it's like coming at airports, or something
it's a moral emotion that emerges during the pre school years, a shame, guilt and, and
where there could be arguments about why you know you wouldn't want someone to not be capable of this moral motion like but
There are so many reasons to like think that could be very toxic motion. I spend a lot of time
My twenties feeling like
even would say out loud, and I said
we re in my journal, like I'm a bad person like for whatever reason like you,
challenge tortuous, some expectation or hidden
ridiculous. I like getting eat healthy that day with a bad person, and I think shame like
can be so deeply
tearing and I'm glad that lake. I grew up.
Little bit announced if fifty and like I, I don't
that kind of like
self incrimination that I that I had one of the younger women not nearly as much anyway. I think aid well
not everybody, but I feel like some time age helps. I mean I do
there are plenty of times where the fifty four and and where I have met.
Top arrived on the wrong thing or said the wrong. They cause harm. I've. I've gotten
this habit of justice when I'm starting to feel that thing inside of me, asking like at the time that I made this choice or did the saying or said this thing,
I feel it was right action and do I still
and if the answer is no- and sometimes it's not that only a candy,
since this was messed up,
But if the answer is yes, then it just at allows it to settle differently.
So the question you ask is why again like it,
What was it right? Wasn't right action
it's sort of like a bit of a buddhist frame yet, but it
works for me for some reason and and annette also sometimes helped me understand when I need to right a wrong yeah. No, I think
Das questions. Obviously too many ways. I was thinking
if I had a new year's resolution, if you can have a nears resolution like September wealth,
school year anyway. I'm about to start
teaching two classes and us
you know what I need
work on the seer and anders ericsson would very much endorse. This cause should have a specific goal for improvement, not just kind of try to prove everything. I am going to really try to ask more questions like more
and take open, ended questions that don't have a year, yes or no right or wrong. Answer
and so I love that you asks questions as a matter of being and I ended
try to do that more like in everything, Brian greaser, whose a person I really Meyer, very curious, pursued and also of you know, come
film, producer, etc.
It had a conversation them recently. He has this idea of a curiosity conversation and that's how
met, but then of course became friends and
he was saying how like in his leadership as as every hollywood producer also has to be a leader like he's learned
of telling people. You know,
to do and what not to do is to
questions, but you know that
are much more.
generative and don't make people
but anyway, I just think it's great, unlike like yeah questions, questions are great.
you're a superpower like. I am not asking enough like real questions,
I love every made. It s a really nice segouin to your podcast. Oh yeah
I you think that's we. We have a pocket, we meaning stephen donor and I have a pot. Gas coordinates stupid question.
yeah I mean with everything else is going on. Your life is not unduly literally, other has weekly like he was like I was like, so when is it sees it over,
I was I was, as you know like as it ten episodes at it was like.
I'm not sure I know you mean like while I mean you know and then like we take a break them
You know that in the next year it is like. Oh
Do you not read any of the emails like? This is a relief I guess it was like god it check.
so.
It's been more frequent, but I'd really like thought. That's my my fault and
he likes even talk about like nice. People like
Stephen has a biased like I. I now know him pretty well like he really
likes
good nice people and so and he's a good nice person. So we get along.
The I that an end is certainly the perfect to have two goodnight.
People who are sitting there. How hosting conversations originally called that near the pike has called no stupid questions, really
basically inviting everybody say come on just like like what he got you now, let's go there, but some
I bet you swore I am, I think
top address? Like super cool you you
when into something which I think for a lot of people super relevant now, which is why it is so hard to be alone with your thoughts was
one of them, and I would imagine a lot of people are going through that question
these days, yeah I'm in the pandemic, is a time when
some people. I mean I think about my mother in law. My mom like they are
like really alone right, I mean they're they're sequestered in with very few exceptions there,
You know they have a hundred and sixty eight hours in their weak, just like we all do but like mama,
all those efforts are alone
I was talking to stephen donor about this question. I think he is hard for me to remember which questions he s me and which I ask him.
picture of this package. Is that it's one of each so there?
You quit conversations that
students, you send us emails or like this when I miss about college like this is the kind of units like fun.
Conversation that I used to have powers in attendance and that question I think he asked me, but I kept
sure it immediately made me think of research,
item wilson and cut
eggs, unhealthy bore so
a averse to being alone.
Their thought city, even for many of them, rather shocked themselves electrically a great pain ratan.
do nothing that then sit there with their thoughts. It also reminded me, by the way of the marshmallow task, which is this famous tacit preschool.
We are waiting in a room, it's empty, there's, nothing in the room to do or look at, and they
are delaying gratification. Hoping till I get
marshmallows instead of one if they can wait until the experimenter comes back, and I remember watching the video of this region,
we'll task and then also replicating this experiment myself with slightly
children and it struck me that you know maybe even harder than waiting and resisting a marshmallow is not doing anything
and I do think that's part of the reason why the task works is that
it's very, very difficult to sit alone,
Some people would like nothing more than to be alone with their thoughts, and I think it's something we can all learn witches. You know
Mindfulness I mean if, if mindfulness becomes part-
parcel of what people learn to do when they grow up in practice when they are
at any age like I think that will be a. I think I can only imagine how wonderful the world is. Gonna be, but my
when this, I think, is not judge metal awareness of the present and I'm guessing that if you had like what you gave us in a room, you know by himself for not only minutes, but ours like you'd, be very good. If you like call here, I am
Yeah, it's it's a really hard experience for so many people, and I have
better. Ten year issue,
adaptation such my father's practice,
So I've got a lot more comfortable with it, but on the sometimes really enjoy it, but it's been
ah process. Is it hard? Are you is it it's not really? Is it out you? How do you describe the experience of you know when you're practicing mindfulness now either
but to me it s her split into two things. One is a sitting practice and one is just an ethos so at, but I think this sitting practice builds thick
osity further eat those that you just character at your day, so I can much more readily just snapping
the conversation a moment and interaction in our tiny green book.
Crawling up my hand, much more easily
I've had doesn't really right.
Jo Leinen answer that I don't care.
The daily practice is fun or necessarily any easier than it was ten years ago, when I started
but I notice the flow through to its moment
I my waking orientation that we're out
not for a moment I ll be like how am I more.
as an or unless reactive, like, I just I know five years ago, I would have experienced this in a much more way and would have led to a
where's outcome for everybody said
No, it's almost it it's that which is actually
much more meaningful thing to do.
That makes sense. I'm learning I dont
the daily mindfulness practice.
Unless you can't yoga- which I think I think reduce the kitten count as moving mission, but I think you really love to have heard you
that, because when he communicates to me what it really means when he's like, it's not necessarily its, it really is just being able to you know throughout your day, justin
like being that state, which is, I guess why. Why do you do that? Deliver I mean it's not that
from exercise right. It's like
one of the vital throughout the day. That is why it helps to do
now you know calisthenics or something here right,
My ultimate goal is not to be able to sit for long or longer amounts of time. I could care less about. What I care about is how it how it changes the quality of my life just moving through each day, which feels like a good place for us to kind of come full circle as well so city,
at air in this container of the good life project. If I offer up the phrase to live a good life, what comes up to me to live a good life is to do three
things why
is to exercise strengths of heart, which is just about you and other people.
So you could say: oh I'm gonna, do that through gratitude or
my mom do through gender.
stealing your kindness. You could do it through. However, you want, but it's a way of interacting with other people in a positive way,
then there's exercising strength of mind like you,
asking questions and been curious, or maybe
being a deep learner, or you might say, like mine
The mind is intellectual humility. I think there are many ways you can enter, that bit strikes a mine and then there's, but I study strength of will. Grit and
control optimism
growth mindset and I think
while the kind of like getting things done. So so, when my dad said you know, life has
tourism charmers. You know
the roughly correspond to these.
allegory is not exactly that order, but I do think if you imagine a person's life who there in some way like working on trying to interact with other people in a given,
the way in some way there trying to like exercise life, the mine we could
there. If you wanted, and in some way to try to get things done for higher purpose and and being effective like,
hard to imagine that you go to wrong color that, thank you,
well. Thank you so much for listening, and thanks also to our fantastic sponsors who helped make this show possible. You can check them out in the links we have included in today's show notes and while you're at it, if you've ever asked yourself. What should I do with my life? We have created a really cool online assessment that will help you discover the source code for the work that you're here to do. You can find it at spark: a type dot com, that's s, p, a r K, e t y pe dot com or just click, the link in the show notes, and, of course, if you haven't already done so, be sure to click on the subscribe button in your listening app. So you never miss an episode and then share share the love. If there's something that you've heard in this episode, that you would love to turn into a conversation, share it with people and have that conversation, because when ideas become conversations that lead to action, that's when real change takes hold, see you next time.
Transcript generated on 2023-06-22.